🐋🧭🗺️❤️✝️🌍 The Irony of the Great Commission: Go and Make Disciples of All "Gentiles" [4 parts]
When Jesus gives the commission in Matthew 28:19—“make disciples of all nations”—the Greek word behind nations is (ethnos). Understanding that term unlocks several layers of meaning and reveals how radical Jesus’ instruction would have sounded to the Jewish men hearing it, one in particular. 📜✨
I. 1. What Ethnos Means in Greek
In Greek usage, ethnos can refer to:
- A people group
- A nation
- A tribe or ethnic community
- Often in Jewish literature, the Gentiles (non-Jews)
The plural (ethnē) frequently functions as shorthand for “the nations outside Israel.”
In the Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures (the Septuagint), ethnos regularly translates the Hebrew word (goyim), meaning nations or peoples, usually referring to non-Israelite nations.
So when Jesus says:
“Make disciples of all ethnē”
His Jewish listeners would likely hear:
“Make disciples among all the Gentile peoples of the world.”
That is a stunning expansion of Israel’s mission. 🌍
2. The Old Testament Background
This command does not appear from nowhere; it fulfills earlier promises.
Abrahamic Promise
Genesis 12:3 - “All the families of the earth will be blessed through you.”
The covenant with Abraham already had global scope. Israel was meant to become a channel of blessing to the nations.
Prophetic Vision
Prophets repeatedly imagined the nations turning toward God:
- Isaiah 49:6 — Israel becomes “a light for the nations.”
- Isaiah 2:2–3 — the nations stream to the mountain of the Lord.
- Isaiah 19:25 — The Lord Almighty will bless them, saying, “Blessed be Egypt My people, Assyria My handiwork, and Israel My inheritance.”
- Zechariah 8:23 — people from many languages grasp the garment of a Jew saying, “God is with you.”
Jesus’ commission activates this long-standing prophetic trajectory.
3. Why This Command Was So Radical
The men hearing Jesus were Jewish disciples shaped by centuries of boundary markers:
- circumcision
- food laws
- purity distinctions
- temple worship
These markers defined Israel as distinct from the ethnē.
Yet Jesus commands them not merely to teach the nations, but to make disciples of them—bringing them into the same covenant community.
This implied that Gentiles could become full participants in the people of God.
The early church wrestled deeply with this implication in events described in Acts, especially:
- Peter and Cornelius (Acts 10)
- the Jerusalem Council (Acts 15)
These episodes show that the disciples themselves needed time to fully grasp what Jesus meant.
4. Ethnos Suggests More Than Geography
The word does not simply mean “countries.”
It refers to distinct peoples.
This means the mission is not merely:
reach every place
but
reach every people group.
In modern missiology, this insight has led to the concept of “unreached people groups.”
The goal is that every ethnic community—language, tribe, culture—would contain disciples of Jesus. This makes sense given that:
Abraham was told all "families" would be blessed through him.
5. A Reversal of Babel
There is also a powerful narrative arc from:
- Genesis 11 — the Tower of Babel, where humanity divides into nations
to - the worldwide mission announced by Jesus.
At Babel, languages scattered humanity into ethnē.
Through the gospel, disciples are gathered from every ethnos into one kingdom.
This trajectory culminates in the vision of worship in:
Revelation 7:9 - “A great multitude from every nation (ethnos), tribe, people, and language.”
6. The Disciples Would Hear an Echo of Daniel
Jewish listeners might also connect Jesus’ authority claim (“all authority in heaven and on earth”) with the vision in:
Daniel 7:14 - “All peoples, nations, and languages served Him.”
The Messiah receives universal allegiance—and the disciples are sent to announce it.
7. Theological Implication
The command reveals something profound about God’s character:
God’s covenant people are not defined by ethnicity. They are defined by discipleship to the Messiah.
The mission therefore moves:
- from Israel alone
- to Israel blessing the nations
- to a multi-ethnic Kingdom of God.
✅ In short:
The use of ethnos means Jesus was not merely sending His disciples abroad. He was commissioning them to bring every people group into the family of God.
For Jewish fishermen from Galilee, this was nothing short of a world-redefining assignment. 🌎🔥
II. Jonah as the Test Case
The command to make disciples of all ethnē takes on deeper weight when read against the story of Jonah. In many ways, Jonah exposes the exact moral and spiritual obstacle that would have made Jesus’ commission nearly impossible:
Can God’s people truly desire mercy for their enemies? 🤔
Jonah is sent to Nineveh, the capital of Assyria.
We should not sanitize this context. Assyria was one of the most brutal imperial powers of the ancient world. Their inscriptions and reliefs boast of:
- mass executions
- flaying prisoners alive
- impaling enemies
- deporting conquered populations
For Israelites, Nineveh represented national trauma and oppression.
Yet God sends a prophet there.
This is not merely a preaching assignment. It is a spiritual test.
Jonah’s Real Objection
Jonah’s resistance becomes clear near the end of the narrative. He admits why he fled:
“I knew that You are a gracious and compassionate God, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love.”
His complaint is not that God might destroy Nineveh.
His complaint is that God might forgive them. 😬
The Moral Question at the Heart of Jonah
The book forces a difficult question:
Can you accept God showing mercy to the people who hurt you?
Or more sharply:
- Can you wish repentance for those who oppressed you?
- Can you hope they receive forgiveness?
- Can you rejoice if God restores them?
Jonah cannot.
When Nineveh repents, he becomes angry enough to ask for death.
Why This Matters for the Mission to the Nations
Fast-forward centuries.
In Matthew 28:19, Jesus sends Jewish disciples to make disciples of all ethnē.
But many of those nations had historically been:
- conquerors
- oppressors
- idolaters
- enemies of Israel
Without the theological challenge posed by Jonah, this command would feel morally outrageous.
Jonah establishes a critical truth:
God’s mercy is not restricted by human hostility. If God can forgive Nineveh, He can forgive any nation.
Jesus Invokes Jonah for a Reason
Jesus explicitly references Jonah in:
Matthew 12:41 - “The men of Nineveh will stand up at the judgment…”
This statement carries an implicit critique.
Nineveh—an enemy nation—responded to a reluctant prophet. Yet many in Israel resisted a far greater messenger.
The irony is sharp:
Those once seen as the worst of the ethnē may respond faster to repentance than those who assume themselves righteous.
This had hints of:
Matthew 21:31 - Jesus said to them [the chief priests and the elders of the people], “Truly I tell you, the tax collectors and prostitutes are entering the kingdom of God ahead of you.”
Jonah Exposes the Greatest Barrier to Mission
The biggest barrier to reaching the nations is not:
- distance 🌍
- language 🗣️
- culture 🏺
It is resentment.
You cannot sincerely invite someone into God’s mercy if you secretly don't want them to have it.
The Gospel Resolves Jonah’s Dilemma
The cross re-frames the entire issue.
Romans 5:8 - “While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.”
If salvation comes while people are enemies, then the mission to the nations is not surprising—it is inevitable.
Every disciple stands in the same position: forgiven enemy turned messenger of mercy.
The Hidden Questions of the Great Commission
Underneath Jesus’ command lies questions similar to the one posed in Jonah:
Do you want God’s mercy to reach the people you dislike most? How about those you hate? Those who have persecuted you, perhaps without reason?
The mission to the ethnē is therefore not only geographic. It is spiritual transformation of the messenger.
Before someone can disciple the nations, they must confront Jonah’s question in their own heart.
The Story Ends with a Question
Notably, the narrative in Jonah ends with God asking:
“Should I not have concern for Nineveh?”
The text never records Jonah’s answer.
That silence leaves the question hanging—for every reader, and for every generation sent to the nations.
III. 1. The Command Was Given in Enemy Territory
The instruction in Jeremiah 29:7 is one of the most strategically important moments in shaping Israel’s moral imagination. It quietly lays groundwork for the later global mission announced by Jesus.
What looks like a simple pastoral instruction to exiles actually reprograms how God’s people think about foreign nations.
“Seek the peace and prosperity of the city to which I have carried you into exile. Pray to the LORD for it, because if it prospers, you too will prosper.”
This statement is astonishing when placed in its historical setting.
Jeremiah speaks to Judeans living under the power of Babylon—the empire that destroyed Jerusalem and the temple.
The empire itself is central to the story of Jeremiah and later narratives in Daniel.
Under normal ancient logic, oppressed people were expected to:
- long for the collapse of their conqueror
- pray for revenge
- cultivate resentment toward the ruling power
Instead, God instructs Israel to pray for the flourishing of their captors.
That command overturns instinctive tribal thinking.
2. “Seek the Peace” – The Word Shalom
The Hebrew word translated “peace and prosperity” is shalom.
Shalom is far richer than the English word peace. It includes:
- stability
- well-being
- flourishing
- harmony within society
So the instruction is not passive tolerance.
God tells His people to actively work toward the flourishing of a foreign society.
That means building, planting, contributing, and praying for the good of the broader community.
3. Exile Becomes Spiritual Training
Exile becomes more than punishment; it becomes formation.
Israel is forced to learn how to live faithfully among the nations rather than apart from them.
Figures like those in Daniel embody this posture:
- serving foreign kings
- demonstrating wisdom and integrity
- seeking the welfare of the empire while remaining loyal to God
This experience gradually reshapes Jewish expectations about interacting with the wider world.
4. Jeremiah Prepares the Heart for a Future Mission
When Jesus later tells His disciples in Matthew 28:19 to make disciples of all ethnē, that command does not emerge in a vacuum.
Centuries earlier, God had already taught Israel:
- to pray for foreign cities
- to seek the flourishing of non-Israelite societies
- to recognize that their well-being is intertwined with the nations
Jeremiah plants the seed that God’s purposes extend beyond Israel’s borders.
5. The Logic of Shared Prosperity
Jeremiah’s reasoning is fascinating:
“If it prospers, you too will prosper.”
This establishes a theological principle:
The welfare of God’s people is connected to the welfare of the nations around them.
That idea anticipates the broader biblical vision in which:
- Abraham’s descendants bless the world (Genesis 12:3)
- the nations stream toward God (Isaiah 2)
- people from every nation worship together (Revelation 7)
Israel’s role is not isolation but participation in God’s restoration of humanity.
6. Jeremiah Softens the “Jonah Problem”
When placed next to Jonah, Jeremiah’s instruction becomes even more significant.
Jonah resists the idea that enemies could receive mercy.
Jeremiah, by contrast, commands God’s people to:
- pray for their enemies
- desire their flourishing
- accept that their future is linked to them
Jeremiah trains the community to want good for people they might otherwise despise.
7. Jesus Extends the Logic Even Further
Jesus builds directly on this trajectory.
He teaches:
- love your enemies (Matthew 5:44)
- pray for those who persecute you
- go and make disciples of all nations (Matthew 28:19)
The pattern becomes clear:
Jonah → shouldn't you be like God, who is concerned for those who harmed you?Jeremiah → seek the welfare of the city
Jesus → love your enemies
Jesus again → disciple the nations
Each step pushes God’s people further outward in mercy.
8. The Formation of a Global People
Jeremiah’s instruction subtly shifts Israel from a purely national identity toward a missional identity.
Instead of asking:
“How do we survive among the nations?”
God invites them to ask:
“How do we bless the nations we live among?”
That question ultimately blossoms into the Great Commission.
9. God Was Preparing Hearts Long Before the Commission
Seen this way, the Great Commission is not an abrupt change. It is the culmination of a long divine strategy.
Through:
- Abraham’s promise
- prophetic visions
- the experience of exile
- the challenge of Jonah
God gradually expands His people’s capacity to desire mercy for the world.
By the time Jesus speaks the words “make disciples of all nations,” the soil has been tilled for centuries.
✅ In essence:
Jeremiah taught God’s people to pray for the flourishing of foreign cities.
Jesus then sends them to bring those cities the knowledge of God Himself.
The prayer for the city becomes the mission to the nations. 🌍✨
IV. 1. What “Zealot” Implies
The presence of Simon the Zealot among the disciples who received the Great Commission adds an extraordinary layer of tension and meaning to Jesus’ command.
It turns the instruction to disciple the ethnē from a theological statement into something intensely personal and costly. ⚔️➡️❤️
In the disciple lists in Luke 6:15 and Acts 1:13, Simon is identified as “the Zealot.”
Whether this means:
- he formally belonged to the revolutionary movement later known as the Zealots, or
- he was known for zealous nationalist passion for Israel,
the label clearly signals strong anti-Roman sentiment.
The Zealot spirit was fueled by ideas drawn from stories like:
- Phinehas’ violent zeal in Numbers 25
- the revolt celebrated in 1 Maccabees
This tradition viewed violent resistance against pagan domination as faithfulness to God.
Rome, therefore, was not just another nation. To many Jews it represented:
- oppression
- idolatry
- humiliation
- occupation of the land promised by God
2. The Great Commission Confronts Zealotry
When Jesus tells His followers to make disciples of all ethnē in Matthew 28:19, the instruction implicitly includes Rome itself.
For Simon the Zealot, that command carries a shocking implication:
The empire he once would have wanted to overthrow becomes a people he is commanded to disciple. This is not merely tolerance.
It means:
- teaching Romans the ways of God
- seeking their salvation
- hoping for their repentance
- risking rejection or death in order to bring them mercy
The revolutionary sword is replaced with the missionary path.
3. From Killing Romans to Loving Romans
Jesus’ teaching throughout His ministry had already begun dismantling the logic of violent nationalism.
He taught:
- love your enemies
- pray for those who persecute you (Matthew 5:44)
Those words are abstract until you imagine them landing in the ears of someone like Simon. For Simon, the “enemy” was not theoretical. It wore Roman armor.
4. The Irony of the Cross
The transformation becomes even sharper when we consider how Jesus was executed. He was crucified by Roman authority, as described in John 19.
Yet from that same cross Jesus prays:
“Father, forgive them.”
If the crucified Messiah can ask forgiveness for Roman executioners, His followers cannot justify hatred toward Rome.
For Simon the Zealot, discipleship now means imitating that posture.
5. The Commission Requires Risk
Making disciples of Rome would require real danger.
Preaching the lordship of Jesus in the heart of the empire meant proclaiming that ultimate authority belongs not to Caesar but to Christ.
This is precisely the tension we see unfolding throughout the missionary efforts recorded in Acts.
The disciples were not merely traveling teachers. They were witnesses whose message often placed them in conflict with imperial authority.
For Simon, loving Romans might mean:
- imprisonment
- torture
- execution
The call to love enemies becomes literal.
6. The Disciples Themselves Become the Sign
The composition of the disciples itself embodies the gospel’s reconciliation.
The group included:
- Matthew, a tax collector who worked with Rome
- Simon the Zealot, associated with anti-Roman zeal
Under ordinary circumstances, those two men would likely have regarded each other with deep suspicion or hostility.
Yet Jesus places them on the same mission.
The gospel first reconciles enemies within the disciples before sending them to reconcile the world.
7. The Mission Rewrites Loyalty
The Great Commission reorders allegiance.
For Simon the Zealot, loyalty to the Kingdom of God now means:
- not destroying Rome
- but offering Rome repentance and forgiveness
The enemy becomes a potential brother.
This fulfills the long preparation we see in:
- Jonah confronting resentment toward enemy nations
- Jeremiah teaching exiles to seek the welfare of foreign cities
Jesus brings these threads together and turns them into action.
8. The Deep Challenge of the Commission
Seen through Simon’s eyes, the Great Commission asks something profound:
Are you willing to bring God’s mercy to the very people you once wanted defeated?
The mission to the nations is not simply geographic expansion. It is the conversion of the disciple’s own heart.
✅ In Simon’s case, the command meant this:
The man who might once have dreamed of Rome’s destruction
is now called to risk his life so that Romans might inherit the Kingdom of God.
That transformation may be one of the most powerful demonstrations of what the gospel actually does to a human being. 🌍✝️